Polk has written its name among the renowned brands for its great audio equipment. From bookshelf speakers to tower speakers there are thousands of amazing products. Such a series of bookshelf speakers is the Signature series. Consumers have praised it highly; also, the speakers of this series are budget-friendly.
So, for the Polk lover, today we are gonna explore Polk S10 VS S15 VS S20 And Alternative Comparison; in case you want some more options. In the end, you can choose the perfect Polk Bookshelf for you.
Polk S10 vs S15 vs S20: Comparison Table
Some related articles:
Polk S10 Review
What’s in the box?
- 2 Polk S10 Bookshelf loudspeakers
- 2 Grille
- Self-adhesive rubber feet
- Wall-mountable template
- Owner’s Manual
Product Description
Polk S10 is a compact satellite designed so it can fit anywhere and with any kind of sound. It gives a neutral sound profile that enhances every movie or home theater experience. The dynamic sound is perfect for getting a place in the home theater setup.
The sound is clear with lower distortion so you enjoy relaxing music or movie. It has a great woofer, tweeter, or other features which makes it worth it. That 1’’ round shape Terylene tweeter efficiently produces high frequency. The high-resolution dome tweeter helps to get lower system resonance which produces detailed high frequency. The result is you can hear every vocal or instruments sound.
Then the mica-reinforced polypropylene cones produce the clean bass and increase the beauty of the sound. Cones have a surrounding of butyl rubbers. Moreover, Conex fiber spiders and ceramic motor structure both are present in the structure a more nice, rich bass. The durability of this type of woofer is super good too.
There is another feature of two-way crossover. This pushes the sound to be more lifelike, realistic, and wider. So, you can feel that you are sitting in front of a live show.
Note that this speaker is compatible with Dolby Atmos and DTS so this is a huge plus point for getting a more vibrant sound.
Lastly, with the amazing sound, this speaker has a beautiful design. The body is small with a stylish look. This look can go with any room décor beside your bed or if you want to place it in your living room, then definitely your guest is going to impress.
The design not only gives a good look but also helps to make the sound clean. Non-resonant Meddite MDF construction prevents unwanted airflow or waves and reduces unwanted distortion.
Product Differentiator
Compact size can fit any room. Has a spacious sound stage and is budget-friendly.
Polk S15 Review
What’s in the box?
- 2 Polk S15 Bookshelf loudspeakers
- 2 Grille
- Self-adhesive rubber feet
- Wall-mountable template
- Owner’s Manual
Product Description
Every speaker belonging to the signature series is super both in sound quality and outer structure. All the three speakers from Polk S-series have the almost same design but in three different sizes.
With the modern cabinet and black walnut finish, they can complement any room decor. In the living room or bedroom, according to your room size, you can S-series speakers.
They have a curved edge and anti-diffraction grills for protecting inner elements. The build quality is also good for becoming a quite long-run friend.
Very few speakers are promising like this who makes the design such that they can also make the sound good and Polk is one of them.
With the beautiful texture, it provides a buttery texture sound too. This S15 can produce precisely crossover, balanced mid and highs. The dynamic kind of sound can fill every corner of a room.
This is close to realistic sound to make your everyday TV or home theater experience into some real one. A clear sound stage can make anyone’s day better. A highly resolute sound perfect for music or movies.
Several features work behind this technology, and the important role among them played by the tweeter and woofer. Mica-reinforced polypropylene woofer with 1-inch high-resolution Terylene dome tweeter.
Only the better-quality tweeter and woofer can produce a spacious, dedicated sound system. For this, the size and material need to be good. And this is exactly Polk S-15 speaker has.
Both the tweeter and woofer have excellent material so they easily gift the consumer a pleasing sound.
When tweeters effortlessly produce impressive highs at the same time woofers also provide a rich bass. Combinedly, they make nice smooth audio for any kind of content.
Product Differentiator
Polk S15 gives more precise and better-quality sound than S10 also a bit bigger.
Polk S20 Review
- What’s in the box?
- 2 Polk S20 Bookshelf loudspeakers
- 2 Grille
- Self-adhesive rubber feet
- Wall-mountable template
- Owner’s Manual
Product Description
Polk S20 is undoubtedly the best speaker in this series and also compared to other competitors. It brings a new home theater experience that can take your movie experience to the next level like you are sitting in a movie theater.
For music lovers, it can give the most realistic tone ever you would feel that you hearing the original content. In the loudest music, you feel a concert feeling just as the artist is standing right before you.
All thanks to Polk’s advanced technology and hard work. Admittedly, it is rich with many high features but what you can find new in it is the Polk patented Power Port technology.
This feature was absent in the Polk S10 and Polk S15, and most probably Power Port tech makes it the best choice ever. All music lovers or movie lovers become concerned about the bass or the low frequency.
Polk resolves this problem by introducing this technology. Any bass lover like me will definitely become surprised after having this feature in their speaker. This tech just ensures a smooth airflow between the speaker and you; which directly hit the ears.
You can feel the hard punch of bass in your ears so you can enjoy your movie or music with full thrill. This minimizes the distortion as much as possible and honestly, if you are not a sound expert you won’t be able to catch the distortion at all.
Besides, there are the mica reinforced polypropylene cones surrounded by butyl rubber. For the dynamic bass, this woofer has also the core role. The material is excellent the size is praised can crack to any low frequency precisely.
The tweeter is also great contains a ceramic motor structure. It is made with Terylene and Conex fiber spiders. This helps to stay at a balanced temperature and these materials can bear high temperatures so no worry about the damage.
If you want your speaker to provide both high and low frequency clearly then focus on the material along with the size. Polk S20 is rich on both sides that make it perfect for TV, home theater, or other purposes.
The design is coming with is like the S10 and S20 but you can the bigger version of them. The black finish is matte and beautiful. There is an anti-diffraction, magnetic grill you can attach or remove.
The modern MDF cabinet with round edges enhances the beauty. Like I have always said this kind of design compliments any room decor. But seeing the sound quality and features it is recommended to use this speaker in big rooms to get the full speaker experience.
Product Differentiator
Much bigger and improve sound and bass compared to S10 and S15. Suited for big rooms and can be the best companion of the home theater system.
Polk S10 VS S15 VS S20: Detailed Comparison
There are very few comparisons between Polk S10 VS S15 VS S20. But this slight difference has a great impact on the sound quality. So, this section is going to help you figure out what type of sound you want.
Also, will help you understand some basic information about the sound quality how can you measure it. Without an expert, you can find the best speaker for you.
High-quality Tweeter For Great High-Frequency Response
Tweeters or drivers are an important part of a speaker, as only they can produce an efficient high-frequency response. All three Polk Signature series speakers have the same 1’’ Terylene dome tweeter.
This extends the low resonance and a dynamic sound stage. Every good brand becomes concerned with the high-frequency response. So, they try to get the best material and 1’’ is a size.
All their speakers here produces the right amount of frequency response. So, here the actual difference is not noticeable. But this is for sure that you won’t be disappointed about the tweeter performance.
Woofer
Here comes the best part of a speaker and the most worrying matter for the bass lovers. A woofer is the only equipment in a speaker that produces the low frequencies that means the bass.
Punchy and powerful bass can change the movie or music experience totally. In every scene dramatic or romantic the punch of sound can turn the scene into the real one. S10 has an average woofer, but S15 and S20 come with a bigger woofer version. Like the woofer, several features have been updated, but each of them is worth praising for sure.
The material and the size are the big facts in a woofer. All three speakers have the same material woofer but the difference is visible in the sizes. And this makes a huge difference in the quality of the sound.
Polk S10 has a 4″ mica-reinforced polypropylene Dynamic Balance® cone driver. Polypropylene is a kind of cone material that the renowned brand Klipsch uses frequently. You can think of its great performance.
Then comes the size. Honestly speaking 4’’ woofer size is not enough for giving a powerful hit of bass. It can work on an average scale but cannot reach a high level.
If we compare it with others then 4’’ is not gonna work. But instead of comparing if we measure the performance of this alone then definitely this is a decent quality speaker.
Then talking about Polk S15, it has a bit big woofer that is 5.25’’. Most of the speakers contain this size woofer that is decent and can give a slight punch of bass but not the deepest form of bass you can expect from it.
But as S10 had a small size woofer that kind of woofer is good for a small size room. But Polk S15 can be suitable for medium or big rooms. It can fill the room with amazing sounds.
Also, another thing to be noted is that the tweeter is the same for all three speakers but that combines with the woofer, which affects the audio quality. They work together and give a beautiful balance dynamic high and low frequency.
The beautiful result is lifelike music or audio content you can enjoy.
The same thing is for S20. But this speaker gives the most precise and splendid quality sound because it has the biggest woofer among the two others.
6.5’’ woofer can give a wall-shaking performance. Any form of audio whether it can a piece of soft music or jazz, rock or other every beat you can catch like the heart pumping.
Your wall would start shaking literally. This speaker gives a tough competition to another high-quality speaker mostly because of the big woofer.
Winner: The winner is clearly S20. But the rest of the speakers also have a balance woofer and low-frequency performance according to their mechanism.
Frequency Response
Perfect frequency response can enhance the whole sound quality but an imbalance frequency response can destroy the whole thing in a minute. This is why it is necessary to check the frequency response.
A frequency range of 50 Hz or below is the best for the defined and clear audio. This rate differs from speaker to speaker according to their other criteria price range.
Polk S10 has a range between 67-40,000 Hz, which again couldn’t satisfy its consumer totally. But admittedly this range is good enough. The reason is in the price range if you see other speakers then you can notice they have a much higher frequency range which makes the sound quality a total disaster.
But Polk improved this feature in S15 by converting the range between 50-40,000 Hz. This can be taken as a good frequency as 50 Hz is a human ear audible. That’s why under this every audio hears clear.
But is Polk S20 is best in every criterion as it has every updated feature than S10 and S15, the frequency response is 39-40,000 Hz.
With the impressive tweeter, 6.5 woofers, and this frequency you can expect to hear every word from your TV happen to be real. If you have a 4K or high-resolution TV then be ready for the lifelike and real movie experience ever.
What you are going to hear you would feel all things are happening around you.
Winner: S20
Good RMS Power Handling Capacity Has A Good Effect On Sound
The RMS power of peak power is another factor that works behind the good sound. For smooth performance, a sufficient amount of power is needed.
Both S10 and S15 have 20-100 power handling capacity. For the S10, this amount is good but as S15 has some updated features and the performance has updated too bit more, RMS may enhance the performance.
Apart from these two speakers, the S20 has up to 125-watt power. For handling the high-end performance, detailed sound in the loudest form is not a tough task for it in 125 watts.
Which has the best sound quality?
You have already figured out which one is the ultimate winner between Polk S10 VS S15 VS S20. Yet some criteria are left behind to discuss.
The impedance and the sensitivity rate decide the loudness and the ancientness in a speaker. All three speakers have the same 8-ohm impedance. This is perfect and no argument about this fact.
The question is now about the sensitivity rate. A sensitivity rate above 80 dB is considered the loudest. S10 VS S15 VS S20 have this rate 87 dB, 88 dB, 88 dB respectively.
Therefore, which speaker you choose your room or home is going to shake. Even this may disturb your roommates or housemates. For the rock type music lover or those who love concert can have a live concert in your home now.
Polk S10 has all the decent features, and the sound is perfect for TV shows, movies, or music. But we won’t recommend this speaker as a part of the home theater.
But Polk S15 and S20 can be a good choice for both movies or home theater. Now if you want to know which is the best then of course it would be Polk S20. It has the amazing sound quality ever.
This is the ultimate winner and the best speaker of the Signature series. But the price may seem a bit for some but trust me actually they are offering a much affordable speaker.
Comparison For The Best Alternative Speaker Of Polk
If you are not into these Polk speakers then these alternative speakers are for you. Here are some of the best bookshelf speakers from Klipsch, Sony, JBL even Edifier.
You can choose from here too. From a lower price range to an average price, you can get what you are searching for.
Klipsch Synergy Black Label B-200 Review
Klipsch has been people’s favorite for decades and still, they have held the position with their high-quality speaker or any other audio equipment. There are very few brands that can give a competition to Klipsch.
As the best alternative to Polk, this Klipsch Synergy B-200 is amazing. Synergy is one of the famous series of Klipsch and every speaker in this series has amazed the consumers highly.
You can listen to the audio coming from this speaker for hours. The sound is distortion-free, non-fatigued, clear.
There is a big woofer, 5.25’’ and 0.75’’ high materialistic tweeter that produces a deep and defined low and high-frequency response. In every movie or music, you can feel the punchy bass and detailed high frequency, which makes the audio more realistic.
This is recommended to use as a front-facing speaker that can be a part of a home theater. If you have an existing home theater, then this speaker can work best for that.
Or if you planning to set up a home theater, then put this speaker on your list.
Klipsch not only impresses the consumer with the sound quality but also with the design too. The black ash color and a copper color round shape woofer in the front carry the traditional look of Klipsch.
There is the logo of Klipsch too. With a dynamic sound and gorgeous look, you can impress your friends as well can enjoy high-level audio in your home.
Edifier R1280T
Edifier is another great brand that makes some best speakers. In a lower budget range, this speaker is the best option for those who have a tight budget. You can get a full range coverage of dedicated sound which can fill the entire room.
The tweeter works well, and the rest of the features and criteria are also good enough to make the sound amazing. It’s a shame that Edifier didn’t have a big woofer, which may be a disappointment to people who like bass.
The 4’’ woofer is not capable of producing rich bass. But the sound is clear for a movie night or music enjoyment.
Infact, the MDF enclosure and black and wood finish can complement the room decor. This is a beautiful speaker and the dimension is not too big also not too small but in a balance size.
On a lower budget, you can have this speaker in your home.
Sony SSCS5
Sony is always best known for its TV but nowadays they have also great speakers. Those speakers can best work with their TV, but as a single or pair speaker you can also set up this with another brand TV or home theater.
The price is not too big for a bookshelf speaker. This speaker is capable of giving high resolution and room-filling audio. After playing music or watching TV you can feel the surround sound around you.
More realistic sound can make your movie experience like you are watching in the movie theater. Or in the loudest volume, the music hears like the original content.
It also provides a tight, rich bass. The tight bass increases the beauty of the sound a lot.
Final Verdict
This article is about one of the finest speaker series of Polk that is the Signature series with some great alternatives. Polk S10 VS S15 VS S20 are three dedicated speakers with unique sound quality.
Polk S10 comes at a low price and the sound quality is decent. But if you want more then S15 and S20 are for you. Both have fantastic sound quality with a beautiful design.
Last of all some of the best alternative reviews in case you couldn’t figure out among the Polk speakers. So, first of all, know your requirements then go for the one that can make you satisfied with.
Student of Computer Science and Tech Journalist. Read More
